“A Revolution in Education”
Art Bardige with Peter Mili
565 words a 2 minute read
“We haven’t thought very creatively about education…We are in the midst of a once in a century technological revolution, and the last time we did this, in the 20th century, hand-in-hand with the industrial revolution went a revolution in education. We haven’t had near the revolution in K-12 commensurate with the digital revolution we are in the midst of. So I don’t think we are thinking ambitiously enough or investing enough in the young…”The Economist editor-in-chief Zanny Minton Beddoes 12.9.20
WHY IT MATTERS: When students ask, “Why do I have to learn this?”, we must be able to answer: “To prepare you for the world you will inherit by becoming a creative STEM problem solver, data analyzer, and spreadsheet fluent user.”
THE BOTTOM LINE: Eliminate Algebra 1 to make room for this “revolutionary” math that will engage students and promote equity, because:
- Algebra 1 is irrelevant. Spreadsheets do not use or solve equations, the focus of this premier course. “When did you last use the quadratic formula?”
- Algebra 1 is obsolete. Technology has made its paper-based exercises like “solve 3x-5=7”useless. Just “Ask Google” to get the answer in the search box.
- Algebra 1 is the “point of failure.” It needlessly segregates students, prevents high school graduations, and destroys college dreams for so many.
Having both causes students to ask, “Why is y now f(x)?” “Why is x a variable not an unknown?” “What’s the difference?”
- Functions are the foundation of College Algebra, Precalculus, Statistics, Calculus and essential to data analysis, coding, and STEM problem-solving.
- Spreadsheets make functions concrete and visual. A variable is a column of numbers and a function is a rule transforming inputs into outputs.
- Spreadsheets are laboratories that enable students to interact, to ask “What if… not answer “What is__?” and learn math as an experimental science.
- Spreadsheets give all students a fresh start. A new way to learn math independent of past performance, elevators not ladders.
THE NEXT THING: Spreadsheets will revolutionize education like they did business. Once we accept that students no longer need to learn Algebra 1, the entire math curriculum collapses, and like reading, will lose its grade-to-grade sequence.
- Why master paper algorithms for whole numbers, decimals, and particularly fractions when our students won’t ever use them?
- Why learn the concepts in traditional order (add→subtract→multiply→divide) when that order is based on algorithmic complexity not conceptual difficulty?
- Why teach the Algebra 2, Precalculus, Calculus sequence when spreadsheets or other apps make their algorithms/exercises obsolete, and functional thinking unifies their concepts/applications.
THE EVEN BIGGER PICTURE: Math, as the science of patterns for solving real-world problems, has long been the math educator’s dream. But calculation friction, real-world data complexity, and abstract pedagogy have limited us to simplistic artificial exercises. Spreadsheets change that.
- What if Algebra Workshop, Introduces function concepts on spreadsheets that prepare teachers and students for digital age problem-solving.
- What if Math Explorations, A prototype problem-solving library of creative “case studies” ranging across interests, enlivened by “proper” questions, and enriched by visualizations, Web-links, shared activities, datasets, spreadsheet labs.
- What if Math Labs, 125 single-concept student spreadsheet lessons for learning key ideas and applying them using functional thinking and spreadsheets that treat math as an experimental science.